Discover Rare Single-Barrel Bourbon, Without The Hunt
- Single-barrel pours you won't find on any shelf
- We taste 50+ barrels weekly, we reject 94%
- Every box is always worth more than you pay
Explore Our Bourbon Mystery Boxes
Looking for a specific bottle? Browse the Bottle Shop
-
Delivered Fast
-
94% of Barrels Rejected
-
Hard-to-Find Bottles
-
Rare Releases
-
4,000+ Verified Members
-
Credit-Back Promise
-
Craft Distillers Only
discover rare bourbon every monthTHE NEW WAY
Introducing The Bourbon Mystery Box
A more exciting way to discover exceptional bourbon without hunting, guessing, or overpaying.
-
Rare bourbons you'll never find on the shelves
-
Curated bottles chosen by real bourbon drinkers
-
Every box is always worth more than you pay
-
Full credit back if a bottle isn't your taste
-
Delivered fast, secure & free right to your door
All possible because we work directly with craft distilleries, no middlemen, no retail mark-ups.
Explore Our Bourbon Mystery Boxes
How it works
-
1. Choose Your Box
Pick the plan that fits your taste and budget. Skip a month, pause, or cancel from your account in one click.
-
2. We Expertly Curate
Every barrel gets sampled before we buy. Only what survives goes into boxes, usually about 6% percent of what crosses the table.
-
3. Unbox & Enjoy
Bottles arrive with tasting notes and the story behind each barrel, so you know what you're drinking before the first sip.
Let Us Do the Hunting
Discover Our Bourbon Mystery Boxes
The Starter
$99.99/month$100+ value
- 1-2 rare bottles worth $100+
- Full credit back on any bottle
- Free shipping on every order
-
Month 1
PDF + Two Tasting Glasses
$45 Value
Pause, skip or cancel anytime
The Explorer
$149.99/month$170+ value
- 2-3 rare bottles worth $170+
- Exclusive bonuses & allocations
- Full credit back on any bottle
- Free shipping on every order
-
Month 1
PDF + Two Tasting Glasses
$45 Value
-
Month 2
WL Hat + $15 Credit
$45 Value
-
Month 3
First West Extra Aged
$80 Value
BONUSBottlePause, skip or cancel anytime
Most Popular
The Connoisseur
$279.99/month$330+ value
- 3-4 rare bottles worth $330+
- Exclusive bonuses & allocations
- Full credit back on any bottle
- Free shipping on every order
-
Month 1
PDF + Two Tasting Glasses
$45 Value
-
Month 2
WL Hat + $25 Credit
$55 Value
-
Month 3
15 Stars Three Ports
$179 Value
Pause, skip or cancel anytime
From the members' room
What members say when they see what's inside
Why We Reject 94% Of The Bourbons We Taste
We taste 50+ samples weekly...
Most don't make it past the first pour. We're not looking for good bourbon, good bourbon is everywhere. We're looking for the bottles that make you stop mid-sip and ask where it came from.
Our buyers travel directly to the distillery, pull from the barrel, and evaluate every candidate blind. No label bias. No broker influence. If it doesn't earn its place on merit, it doesn't ship.
Hand-Picked
Selected at the source, never from catalogs.
Elite Curation
Our 94% rejection rate is your quality guarantee
Risk-Free
Full credit for any bottle that isn't for your taste.
THE LONGER REVIEWS
Their own photos, Their own words
-
Received my mystery box and was blown away by the bottles.
Only had one of the 5 bottles in the past, and never heard of the others. Well worth the $279 to get $500 in bourbon that I wouldn't have otherwise tasted. Can't wait to see what's next!
Brian Boesch Verified Customer
-
Fantastic and well rounded curation of standout bourbons
I'm still pretty new to the bourbon scene and exploring the huge variety that's out there. One place that really stood out to me is the Whiskey Library. It's an incredible site with an amazing selection that you do not see in your typical brick and mortar. Whether you're a rookie just starting your bourbon journey or a seasoned bourbon drinker, I highly recommend making the Whiskey Library a must-visit.
Tim Leger Verified Customer
-
I am very pleased with my bourbon mystery box!
Just started trying them and off the bat the Stellum is fantastic; cherry pie with brown sugar and oak on the nose, palate is layered with chocolate, toffee, and cinnamon spice. Then finishes oh so smooth with a mild bite at the end. At 115 proof this thing will sneak up on you! Fingers crossed the Easter bunny brings me another box!
Kyle R Verified Customer
-
The bourbon has been great so far.
After the third shipment, I finally received my two sniffer glasses that were not broken. Whiskey library has a great customer service team and addressed my broken glasses immediately by sending out another shipment after I contacted them. The bourbon has been great so far. Thank you
Midwest Bourbon Fan Verified Customer
-
Mystery Box Rocks!!!
Well worth the price, the whiskey you receive is AWESOME!!! Thanks Whiskey Library!!!
Vincent Velasquez Verified Customer
-
Awesome bourbon box for the price
The box had several bourbons I am not able to buy locally. The wife and I really enjoyed doing a sampling. The jimmy red bourbon is now one of our favorites.
Justin Both Verified Customer
-
My first box!
I was pleased with my first box! The products were delivered just as promised by the company! I am excited to see what products are in my next box! No complaints or issues just great whiskey! Thanks
DD Verified Customer
