$274 In Bonuses
-
-
-
-
-
-
BONUS
Bottle
The Bourbon Mystery Box
Discover rare bourbons you won't find on your local shelf, picked by expert tasters and kept secret until you open the box. Every box is a new find, from single barrel picks to custom blends.
Skip, pause or cancel anytime
Enjoy every bottle, or get a credit back.
If a bottle doesn't hit the spot, we credit your account - no hassle, no questions asked.
Order now to receive
What's Inside Each Mystery Box
- 1-4 hand-picked bourbons a month, depending on your box, that you'll almost never see on local shelves
- A mix of rare craft bottles, limited drops and distillery exclusives
- Full-size bottles only: no minis, no samples
- Distillery notes, tasting profiles and bottle stories included
- Secure, protective packaging
Subscription terms
- No commitment: skip or cancel anytime
- Free shipping on every box
- Full credit back on any bottle you don't enjoy
Why Bourbon Drinkers Love This Box
- Discover bottles you'd never find by hunting store to store
- Build a rare, impressive collection without the chase
- Every box is worth more than you pay, guaranteed
- Try new distilleries without wasting money on bottles you may not like
- Perfect for sipping, collecting, or showing off to friends
- A monthly unboxing moment you genuinely look forward to
Why We're Different
The mystery box that actually delivers real value:
- We work directly with craft distilleries: no middlemen, no retail markup
- Every shipment is guaranteed to be worth more than the price you pay
- No filler, no warehouse overruns, no bottles nobody wants
- Risk-free with our full credit-back guarantee
Our Curation Process
We buy barrels ourselves, direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers: single barrels and small blends. If a bottle doesn't earn its place, it doesn't ship. No standing in line. No lottery losses. Just exceptional bourbon delivered monthly.
- Barrel by barrel. Hand-selected at the source, not from a catalog
- Zero risk. Full credit for any bottle that doesn't hit your palate
Our Credit-Back Guarantee
If a bottle simply isn't your taste, you get full credit back, no questions asked.
We stand behind every pick we send, and we want you to love every bottle. This guarantee makes your membership completely risk-free and ensures you only pay for bourbon you truly enjoy.
How It Works
Choose Your Box
Pick Starter, Explorer or Connoisseur, from 1-2 up to 3-4 full-size bottles a month. Checkout takes under a minute, and you can skip, pause or cancel anytime.
We Expertly Curate
Expert tasters try every bottle blind, from rare releases to single barrel picks you won't find on your local shelf. Which ones land in your box stays a secret.
Receive Your First Box
Ships in 1 to 2 business days, arrives 5 to 8 business days after it ships. Tasting glasses and the digital Field Guide come inside. If a bottle doesn't land, you get a credit back.
Join the Community. Build Your Collection.
-
Hand-Picked Craft Bourbons
We buy barrels ourselves, direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers: single barrels and small blends. If a bottle doesn't earn its place, it doesn't ship. -
Guaranteed Value Every Shipment
$170+ for Explorer, $330+ for Connoisseur. Your box is always worth more than you pay or we credit you back. -
Credit-Back Guarantee
If a bottle isn't your taste, you get full credit back. No questions asked. Your membership is completely risk-free. -
Free Shipping on All Orders
Explorer and Connoisseur members get free shipping on every mystery box AND all additional shop orders. Forever. -
Members-Only Allocated Releases
First access to rare single-barrel picks and limited releases at true MSRP. The bottles others line up for, delivered to your door. -
Member Status & Rewards
Unlock Silver, Gold, and Platinum status as you build your collection. Higher tiers = better access, exclusive pricing, and surprise perks.
How We Choose Every Bottle
Over 400 different bottles shipped to members so far.
We buy barrels ourselves, direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers: single barrels and small blends. If a bottle doesn't earn its place, it doesn't ship.
-
400+
Unique Bottles Shipped
33,000+
Boxes Shipped
-
100%
Satisfaction Guaranteed
Customer Reviews
Happy with my first box. I was very skeptical, but received 2 bottles I am looking forward to cracking open. I had been considering signing up for several months and the promo with Brewzle & a Neeley bottle put me over the top. See my story here: https://youtu.be/u3u5dW6PfAU looing forward to the next box.
Very nice selection sent! My all time favorite is the Doc Holiday though. So far i haven't tasted any that beats it. Ive drank 4 bottles so far 2 fingers at a time. Awesome sipping
I did not receive my 15 stars bottle nor did I receive the two glasses and my last box I had a damaged glass and I let that one slide, but I did not get one of my bottles of bourbon and I did not get my two glasses this go around!
Received Doc Holliday 8 year and Old Dominick this month.
Old Dom was good. I wouldn't call it great... but good. Nice smooth drink from nose to mouth to finish. Nothing exceptional, but a decent pour and for the $60... was reasonable-ish.
However, the Doc Holliday 8 year at $120... fell short. Pleasant nose and smooth mouth... the finish was just hot/pepper and way too spicy. In fact, is about the only thing I remember was the finish because it was so overpowering, hot, and unpleasant... and it was lower proof than the OldDom. Tbh I had suspected that the bottle would be greater than the sauce which was why I haven't purchased at the liquor store. At $120, and even in a "cool" bottle, it was not worth it to me. The DocHoll will just sit in the cabinet probably. May use it as a mixing bottle or save it for the unsuspecting.
Hopefully next month's selections will be better. If not, then I'll likely have to reconsider the cost of membership.
my first box had 5 bottles in it, i must say.. that 15 Start Three Ports was outstanding! There was only one i didn't care too much for (Couture Collection 10 year from World Whiskey Society). The others were great! In all i received Neeley Small Batch 5 year, Barrell Bourbon: Tale of two Islands, Couture Collection 10 year, 15 starts three ports, Breckenridge High Proof Blend.
I can't wait to receive my next shipment.
Frequent Asked Questions
What if I hate what I get, am I stuck with it?
You get full credit, no questions, no hoops. If a bottle doesn't hit your palate, contact us and we'll apply the value to your next order. We stand behind every pick we ship.
How do I know this isn't cheap stuff marked up?
We're not a retailer. We don't stock shelves or sell what's easy to get. We buy barrels ourselves, direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers: single barrels and small blends. If a bottle doesn't earn its place, it doesn't ship.
Every bottle is a genuine craft pick from distilleries respected in the bourbon world, not mass-market fillers. Your box is always guaranteed to be worth more than you pay, and if a bottle doesn't hit your palate, you get full credit back.
Is this a subscription that's hard to cancel?
It's a subscription, but a flexible one. Skip a month, pause, or cancel anytime before your next billing date. No penalties, no calls to make. Manage everything directly from your account.
What's the actual difference between the three boxes?
The Starter is perfect if you're new to craft bourbon or want a low-commitment way to explore: 1-2 premium craft bottles each month.
The Explorer is built for the enthusiast who wants to discover: a mix of styles, distilleries and flavor profiles, curated for range and approachability, 2-3 bottles each month.
The Connoisseur is built for the collector: barrel-numbered expressions, aged releases and distillery-exclusive picks that rarely make it onto any shelf, 3-4 bottles each month. All three are hand-selected by our curation team; the Connoisseur just goes deeper. Each box's price and its first three months of rewards are at the top of this page.
What if I already own some of these bottles?
It happens occasionally. If you receive a bottle you already own, contact us and we'll work something out. Our goal is for every box to feel like a find, not a repeat.
When does it arrive and how is it packed?
Ships in 1 to 2 business days, arrives 5 to 8 business days after it ships. You'll get a tracking link the moment your box leaves our hands. Every bottle is packed securely, and a signature is required on delivery.