★★★★★ 4.8 from 4,000+ Bourbon Enthusiasts

Get Over $500 In Value For Your First Bourbon Mystery Box

Limited Offer – Only While Supplies Last
Rare Bourbon Hand-Picked By Experts
Rare Bourbon Hand-Picked By Experts
Bonus Exclusive 15 Stars in Your First Box
Bonus Exclusive 15 Stars in Your First Box
$500+ Value in in Your First Box
$500+ Value in in Your First Box
Get My Bourbon Mystery Box →
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Mystery Bourbon Box with bonus Blanton's
Expertly Curated Expertly Curated
Hard-to-Find Bottles Hard-to-Find Bottles
Rare Releases Rare Releases
Guaranteed Value Guaranteed Value
Credit-Back Promise Credit-Back Promise
Delivered Fast Delivered Fast
Craft Distillers Only Craft Distillers Only
Expertly Curated Expertly Curated
Hard-to-Find Bottles Hard-to-Find Bottles
Rare Releases Rare Releases
Guaranteed Value Guaranteed Value
Credit-Back Promise Credit-Back Promise
Delivered Fast Delivered Fast
Craft Distillers Only Craft Distillers Only
Expertly Curated Expertly Curated
Hard-to-Find Bottles Hard-to-Find Bottles
Rare Releases Rare Releases
Guaranteed Value Guaranteed Value
Credit-Back Promise Credit-Back Promise
Delivered Fast Delivered Fast
Craft Distillers Only Craft Distillers Only
Expertly Curated Expertly Curated
Hard-to-Find Bottles Hard-to-Find Bottles
Rare Releases Rare Releases
Guaranteed Value Guaranteed Value
Credit-Back Promise Credit-Back Promise
Delivered Fast Delivered Fast
Craft Distillers Only Craft Distillers Only
Expertly Curated Expertly Curated
Hard-to-Find Bottles Hard-to-Find Bottles
Rare Releases Rare Releases
Guaranteed Value Guaranteed Value
Credit-Back Promise Credit-Back Promise
Delivered Fast Delivered Fast
Craft Distillers Only Craft Distillers Only
Customer looking at bottles on shelves

Sick of Hunting Stores for Allocated Bottles?

If you're a collector (or want to become one), you already know:

  • The best bourbons never make it to shelves
  • Retailers mark up bottles 3–4x
  • You waste time driving from store to store
  • You still never know if you'll like what you find

The distribution system is broken.
The good bottles rarely reach regular customers.

The Bourbon Mystery Box with bottles The Bourbon Mystery Box with bottles
THE NEW WAY

Introducing The Bourbon Mystery Box

A more exciting way to discover exceptional bourbon without hunting, guessing, or overpaying.

  • Rare bourbons you’ll never find on the shelves
  • Curated bottles chosen by real bourbon drinkers
  • Every box is always worth more than you pay
  • Full credit back if a bottle isn’t your taste
  • Delivered fast, secure & free right to your door

All possible because we work directly with craft distilleries, no middlemen, no retail mark-ups.

Get My Bourbon Mystery Box →
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Hand-Picked

Hand-Picked

Selected at the source, never from catalogs.

Elite Curation

Elite Curation

Our 94% rejection rate is your quality guarantee.

Risk-Free

Risk-Free

Full credit for any bottle that isn’t for your taste.

How It Works

Choose Your Box
1

Choose Your Box

Pick the plan that fits your taste and budget. Choose from a one-time option or a monthly subscription.

We Expertly Curate
2

We Expertly Curate

Our team hand-selects 2–4 bottles from craft distilleries, limited releases and single-barrel picks you won't find in stores for you.

Unbox & Enjoy
3

Unbox & Enjoy

Your box ships within 48 hours. Every bottle includes detailed tasting notes & backstory so you know exactly what you're drinking and why it's special.

Try Bourbon Mystery Box →
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed
Rating stars

4000+ Bourbon Lovers Can't Be Wrong:

95%

Say their box is worth more than they paid

5 Months

Average time members stay subscribed

98%

Would recommend The Mystery Box to a friend
Received my mystery box and was blown away by the bottles.
Review rating

Received my mystery box and was blown away by the bottles.

Only had one of the 5 bottles in the past, and never heard of the others. Well worth the $279 to get $500 in bourbon that I wouldn't have otherwise tasted. Can't wait to see what's next!

Brian Boesch Verified Customer
Fantastic and well rounded curation of standout bourbons
Review rating

Fantastic and well rounded curation of standout bourbons

I’m new to bourbon, and Whiskey Library has been a standout. Their selection goes far beyond a typical store, with something for beginners and seasoned drinkers alike—a great way to explore and expand your palate.

Tim Leger Verified Customer
I am very pleased with my bourbon mystery box!
Review rating

I am very pleased with my bourbon mystery box!

Just started trying them and off the bat the Stellum is fantastic; cherry pie with brown sugar and oak on the nose, palate is layered with chocolate, toffee, and cinnamon spice. Then finishes oh so smooth with a mild bite at the end. At 115 proof this thing will sneak up on you! Fingers crossed the Easter bunny brings me another box!

Kyle R Verified Customer
The bourbon has been great so far.
Review rating

The bourbon has been great so far.

After the third shipment, I finally received my two sniffer glasses that were not broken. Whiskey library has a great customer service team and addressed my broken glasses immediately by sending out another shipment after I contacted them. The bourbon has been great so far. Thank you

Midwest Bourbon Fan Verified Customer
Mystery Box Rocks!!!
Review rating

Mystery Box Rocks!!!

Well worth the price, the whiskey you receive is AWESOME!!! Thanks Whiskey Library!!!

Vincent Velasquez Verified Customer
Awesome bourbon box for the price
Review rating

Awesome bourbon box for the price

The box had several bourbons I am not able to buy locally. The wife and I really enjoyed doing a sampling. The jimmy red bourbon is now one of our favorites.

Justin Both Verified Customer
My first box!
Review rating

My first box!

I was pleased with my first box! The products were delivered just as promised by the company! I am excited to see what products are in my next box! No complaints or issues just great whiskey! Thanks

DD Verified Customer
The Bourbon Mystery Box with bottles
The Bourbon Mystery Box with bottles
Rating 4.8 from 4,000+ Bourbon Enthusiasts

The Bourbon Mystery Box

A more exciting way to discover exceptional bourbon without hunting, guessing, or overpaying.

Limited Edition
The Connoisseur
Mystery Box
$279/mo*
What’s included in your first box:

  • 3–4 Premium Craft Bottles ( $330+ Value)

  • Glassware + $25 Gift Card ($45 Value)

  • Free Shipping with secure packaging ($25 Value)

  • Enjoy every bottle, or get a credit back.

15 Stars Three Ports
Bonus 15 Stars Three Ports
(value $150)
Total value: $535
Payment methods

Enjoy every bottle, or get a credit back.

If a bottle doesn’t hit the spot, we credit your account, no hassle, no questions asked.

Order now to receive on Sunday 2nd August

  • 3–4 hand-picked bourbons you’ll almost never see on local shelves
  • A mix of rare craft bottles, limited drops, and distillery exclusives
  • Full-size bottles only (no minis, no samples, no repeats)
  • Distillery notes, tasting profiles & bottle stories included
  • Fast shipping (48 hours), premium secure packaging

Subscription Terms

  • No commitment — skip or cancel anytime with one click
  • Free shipping on every box
  • Full credit-back guarantee on any bottle you don’t enjoy
  • Discover bottles you’d never find by hunting store to store
  • Build a rare, impressive collection — without the chase
  • Always receive $30–$90+ more value than what you pay
  • Try new distilleries without wasting money on bottles you may not like
  • Perfect for sipping, collecting, or showing off to friends
  • A monthly “unboxing moment” you genuinely look forward to

The Mystery Box That Actually Delivers Real Value:

  • We work directly with craft distilleries — no middlemen, no retail markup
  • Our team rejects over 90% of bottles we sample
  • Every shipment is guaranteed to be worth more than the price you pay
  • No filler, no warehouse overruns, no bottles “nobody wants”
  • Risk-free with our full credit-back guarantee

Our buyers spend their mornings pulling barrel thieves at craft distilleries like Wilderness Trail, New Riff, and Old Forester’s Single Barrel program. They taste 50+ samples to find the 3 that matter. No standing in line. No lottery losses. Just exceptional bourbon delivered monthly.

  • Barrel by barrel. Hand-selected at the source, not from a catalog
  • The 6% that survive. Our 94% rejection rate is your quality guarantee
  • Zero risk. Full credit for any bottle that doesn’t hit your palate

If a bottle simply isn’t your taste, you get full credit back — no questions asked.

We stand behind every pick we send, and we want you to love every bottle. This guarantee makes your membership completely risk-free and ensures you only pay for bourbon you truly enjoy.

What Bourbon Drinkers Like You Are Saying

▶
▶
▶
▶
The Connoisseur Mystery Box $279/mo*

5 Reasons Why Bourbon Lovers

Choose Our Mystery Box

You Get Rare Bottles You’ll Never Find in Stores
Reason 1
You Get Rare Bottles You’ll Never Find in Stores

The whiskey distribution system is broken, most of the good stuff never hits shelves.

Our team works directly with craft distillers and select sources to secure limited releases, single barrels, and small-batch gems normally reserved for insiders.

If you’ve ever walked into a store and found nothing but the usual suspects… this solves that problem.

Every Shipment Delivers $330+ of Real Value
Reason 2
Every Shipment Delivers $330+ of Real Value

On the secondary market, many bottles are marked up 300–400%.

Your Mystery Box bypasses the flippers and hype pricing, giving you true value every month.

You’re paying for premium bourbon — not inflated middlemen.

Expert Curation You Can Trust
Reason 3
Expert Curation You Can Trust

Our tasting panel samples every barrel before it makes the cut.

Only the top 6% of what we taste is selected.

This ensures your box contains bottles that are worth drinking, collecting, and sharing — not leftovers or mass-produced filler.

Insider Access the Public Never Gets
Reason 4
Insider Access the Public Never Gets

As a member, you unlock single-barrel picks you’ll never find in any store and get early access to allocated releases at true MSRP — the bottles other people line up for, hunt for, or overpay for… delivered to you without the hassle.

Total Control, Zero Risk
Reason 5
Total Control, Zero Risk

Skip, pause, or cancel anytime.

If you ever get a bottle that isn’t your taste, you’re protected by our full-credit guarantee.

You get all the upside of rare bourbon… without the risk, time, or hassle of hunting.

Bourbon collector selection
Why collectors love it

Get What Others Hunt For Without The Chase Plus:

  • The thrill of unboxing rare bourbons you’d never find in stores.

  • Surprise bottles selected to expand your palate and collection.

  • A monthly ritual you genuinely look forward to.

  • A growing shelf of impressive bottles that tell a story.

  • A curated tasting experience built for true enthusiasts.

Try Bourbon Mystery Box →
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

Rated & Reviewed by Bourbon Enthusiasts

Northport Location

83 Main Street
Northport, NY 11768

Info

Our Community

Connect with fellow whiskey enthusiasts, get exclusive drops & insider access.

Join Community
Payment methods
© 2025 Whiskey Library | All Rights Reserved