4.8/5
Award-Winning Craft Bourbons You Won't Find Locally, Delivered.
Discover limited-release, single-barrel, and cask-finished craft bourbons. Subscribe today and save 39% off your First Box*
*Applies to Monthly Subscription Only
How it Works
We Taste So You Don't Have To Guess
We sample over 100 bottles monthly—chasing single-barrels, limited releases, and cask finishes that deserve your attention. If it doesn't impress us, it won't reach you.
Craft Bourbon Arrives Without the Hassle
3-4 expertly curated bottles show up at your door with notes that make you sound like an expert at your next gathering. No store runs. No wasted weekends.
Your Taste Drives What's Next
Rate your favorites. We'll remember. Every box becomes more aligned with what you love—because great bourbon is personal.
A PEEK INSIDE THE BOX
$189 Value
Doc Holliday 10 Years Old Single Barrel
A 10-year, single-barrel powerhouse that floods the palate with warm butterscotch, cherry pipe-tobacco, and toasted pecan before a long, pepper-laced oak finish.
$169 Value
Nashville Barrel Single Barrel 10 Year Old
A decade of single-barrel aging unleashes waves of caramelized banana, blackberry jam, and warm cinnamon over toasted oak, finishing with a silky dark-chocolate hug.
$64.99 Value
Jimmy Red Classic Bourbon Whiskey
Jimmy Red Classic Bourbon Whiskey is a rich, full-bodied bourbon crafted from rare heirloom Jimmy Red corn, delivering deep notes of roasted nut, baking spice, and sweet oak with a smooth, enduring finish.
$169 Value
WWS Gargoyle 8 Years Old Armagnac Cask
An eight-year spirit finished in rich Armagnac casks, layering dried apricot, spiced honey, and toasted almond over velvety oak for a luxuriously lingering finish.
$184 Value
Hillrock Solera Aged Bourbon
Solera aging stacks generations of whiskey into a luscious blend of dried fig, vanilla crème brûlée, and spiced oak, ending with a sherry-kissed warmth that lingers.
$59 Value
Old Fitzgerald 7 Years Old Bottled In Bond
A seven-year, Bottled-in-Bond wheated bourbon that greets you with honeyed wheat and butterscotch, then unfolds baked apple, cinnamon spice, and silky oak into a graceful, candy-bar finish.
$100 Value
Remus Repeal VII
Remus Repeal Reserve Series VII is a premium straight bourbon blend from Ross & Squibb (formerly MGP), featuring a medley of five bourbons aged between 9 and 16 years—crafted to honor the repeal of
$54.99 Value
Watershed Bottled in Bond
Watershed Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon is a craft bourbon distilled, aged for a minimum of four years in a bonded warehouse, and bottled at 100 proof (50% ABV)—all made in-house in a single distillation season, offering a true snapshot of Watershed Distillery’s artistry and consistency
What our Customers Say
Bourbon Mystery Box - The Connoisseur
Get 3-4 exceptional craft bourbons worth $330+—single-barrels, limited releases, cask finishes you won't find locally—expertly curated and delivered to your door. in as little as 7 Days.
What's Included
Single-barrels, limited releases, and cask finishes you won't find locally
Connect with fellow enthusiasts, share tasting notes, and learn from experts
Detailed flavor profiles and background for every bottle in your box
First dibs on rare releases before they sell out
Exclusive pricing on bottles you want to purchase separately
Delivered safely to your door
Expert guides and recommendations
Got my first ever subscription box and was thrilled with the diversity of the bottles! Can’t wait to get started on the sampling!
I've tried other subscription boxes before and was disappointed. But, I thought I'd give this one a try and I am extremely happy that I did. Full bottles and great variety and value. Not just something cheap that was easy to find. A great way to discover new quality bourbons! Only one box so far, so hopefully the quality repeats with my next box.
Here on the west coast I haven’t seen any of the Bourbons I got in my box. Love the selection and the bourbons were amazing thanks whiskey library
Through all the conversations I have had with this company. Every time the conversation was pleasant and very helpful. I have looked at three other whiskey subscriptions, and none of them, whereas Personal as this one..
In my first box I received a Doc Holiday 11 year, a Beyond Distilling and a Field & Sound. I'm very pleased with all 3. Looking forward to me next shipment.
FAQ's
What's inside the Mystery Box?
Each box includes 2–4 premium bourbons—from small-batch craft bottles to rare single barrels. You’ll also get tasting notes, exclusive stickers, and the occasional bonus like branded glassware.
Can I choose what’s in the box?
No—and that’s the thrill. Our team curates each box to surprise and impress, pulling from both well-loved and hard-to-find bottles.
Are the bottles rare?
Yes. We source from private picks, craft distilleries, and limited releases. Some boxes even contain allocated or collectible bottles you won’t find on local shelves.
Is it a subscription?
Only if you want it to be.
You can buy a single box or subscribe to receive a new Mystery Box every 3 or 6 months—no pressure, no commitment.
How long does shipping take?
We ship within 48 hours. Most boxes arrive in 5 business days or less.
How do you select the bottles?
Customers love knowing there's real expertise behind the choices. Whiskey Library curates bottles via deep connections in distilleries and a rigorous tasting process.
The Perfect Pour Guarantee
We stand behind every bottle we send. If a bourbon misses the mark, simply let us know within 30 days and we'll credit its value to your account. Apply it to your next box or choose a bottle from our collection. Keep the bottle, share your feedback, and we'll make it right.
One bottle credit per box.