While Supplies Last: Bonus Blanton's with your first Connoisseur box
4.8/5 4,000+ Bourbon Lovers
Bonus Blanton's with Your First Mystery Box- While Supplies Last
Subscribe to The Connoisseur tier and we'll add a bonus Blanton's Single Barrel on top of your regular 2-4 bottle shipment. That's $395+ total value in your first box.
No Commitments | Cancel Anytime | Free Shipping
Limited Time Offer:
Bonus Blanton's with Your First Mystery Box- While Supplies Last
Subscribe to The Connoisseur tier and a get a bonus Blanton's Single Barrel ($65 value) on top of your regular 2-4 bottle shipment. That's $395+ total value in your first box.
No Commitments | Cancel Anytime | Personalized
Curated by Bourbon Drinkers
No filler — just captivating, craft pours we’d proudly drink ourselves.
Enjoy every bottle, or get a credit back.
If a bottle doesn’t hit the spot, we make it right. Simple as that.
Free Shipping & No Hidden Fees
No hidden fees. No subscription traps. Cancel anytime with a click.
New Bourbons in Every Box
Every Single Mystery Box is Unique—no repeats, no duplicates, just endless exploration of single-barrel picks and limited releases you won't find anywhere else.
Guaranteed risk-free exploration experience
Award Winning Bourbon From Craft Distillers
Tasting notes & distillery stories included
Ships in 48 hours with secure packaging
Get Access to Allocated Releases
Upcoming Members Only Releases
Explore with confidence
Every bottle in your mystery box is 100% satisfaction guaranteed—if you don't love a bourbon we select for you, we'll credit you back the full bottle value toward any bottle in our shop
Here’s How It Works
1
Choose Your Box
Pick the plan that fits your taste and budget. Choose from a one time option or a suscribe and save option.
2
We Curate Your Selection
Our team hand-selects 2-4 bottles from craft distilleries, limited releases, and single-barrel picks you won't find in stores for you.
3
Unbox & Enjoy
Your box ships within 48 hours. Every bottle includes detailed tasting notes and backstory—so you know exactly what you're drinking and why it's special.
Over 4000+ Whiskey Enthusiasts Can't Be Wrong
"I’ve been stuck ordering over priced bourbon online for years as the Midwest market is horrible for bourbons.
First bottle I opened was the Old Joe and I’m wondering where it’s been my whole adult life.
Thrilled to keep going and getting these bottles I’ve never heard about."
Chris S
Mayer, MN
"I just received my Mystery Box from Whisky Library, and I was absolutely blown away by the selection. This box was a perfect trifecta of high-quality, high-character bourbons that truly delivered on the promise of rare and curated picks."
Jeremy Nelson
Kissimmee, FL
"I've tried other subscription boxes before and was disappointed. But, I thought I'd give this one a try and I am extremely happy that I did. Full bottles and great variety and value. Not just something cheap that was easy to find. A great way to discover new quality bourbons! Only one box so far, so hopefully the quality repeats with my next box."
Alex B.
Findlay, OH
Choose Your Plan
Select the Bourbon Mystery Box Plan that Best Fits you needs
100% Satisfaction Gurantee
Enjoy Every Bottle or We Credit You
If a bottle doesn’t hit the spot, we credit your account — no hassle, no questions asked.
You get to explore rare, craft whiskey with complete confidence.
I received my first mystery box and was all giddy about it. I was happy to get 7 yrs Doc Holliday and Redwood Empire 😉 The communication with the delivery was great. Thank you for a great selection. Now I’m going to step up to another option.
Very happy with the bottles that I received. Have you yet to open them! I’ll probably wait until I get my next order. But they great look great on my bar.
Just unpacked my first mystery box. Can’t wait to break some new stuff out with the holidays coming up.
I am new to Bourbon and Whiskey and had tried several shelf brands from liquor store and nothing really appealed to my palette. So I took a chance with Whiskey Library and got 4 bottles. I truly have enjoyed each bottle and the tastes are unique for each bottle. My favorite out of this batch is between Red Seal and Rough Rider. They are much better than what I was getting from liquor store. Unfortunately I tend to want to drink every night!! Highly Recommend!
I’ve been mulling over whether or not to give the mystery box a try. But then I just went with my gut and ordered my first box. It definitely met my expectations as being affordable, paired with variety and intrigue. I have a modest collection of 8 and 10 year bourbons but I have not have had any of the 3 that were delivered. Needless to say I’m excited to crack these open and give them a sample. I also look forward to using tasting cards to see where my palate lines up with the descriptions. I’ll definitely order again if this is what I can expect. Thanks
Frequently Asked Questions
No matter what your question is about the magical box, the team at Whiskey Library is always on hand to provide prompt and accurate answers.
Email us at support@whiskeylibrary.com anytime
What if I get a bottle I don't like?
We'll credit its full value toward any bottle in our shop. No hassle.
What if a bottle arrives damaged?
We'll replace it immediately or credit your account. All boxes are packaged securely, but if anything goes wrong, we make it right.
How is this different from Flaviar or Taster's Club?
We're a real retailer, not a marketplace. We own every bottle we sell. No cancellations, no bait-and-switch, no waiting weeks to hear we couldn't source your order.
Can I cancel anytime?
Yes. No tricks, no hidden fees.
Are these just mystery boxes to offload bottles nobody wants?
Absolutely not. We personally taste hundreds of bottles to find the exceptional ones. These aren't overpriced craft whiskeys from hobbyist distillers or young, grainy pours. Every bottle is something we'd drink ourselves—90+ rated single-barrel picks and limited releases worth discovering.
Will I ever get the same bottle twice?
Never. With access to 400+ craft distilleries, we ensure every box brings new discoveries. Your bourbon journey keeps expanding with every delivery—no repeats, no duplicates.
