The Bourbon Box for Collectors Who’ve Outgrown Their Local Liquor Store
2–4 Rare & Craft Bourbons In Every Box
Curated to impress. Delivered to enjoy
Early Access To New Release
You hear about it first—then pour it first
Insider Access to the Whiskey Tribe
Curated to impress. Delivered to enjoy.
How It Works
WE DO THE HARD PART—FINDING THE GOOD STUFF
We go deep into distilleries, sample rooms, and secret shelves to discover bourbon worth freaking out over. Every bottle goes through a tasting gauntlet, and only the exceptional ones survive.
YOU ORDER & GET A MYSTERY BOX OF MAGIC
Your Mystery Box arrives with 2 to 4 bottles you’ve likely never tried—but won’t stop talking about. Every bottle is packed with care and a little swagger.
YOU POUR, SIP, & GET IN ON THE INSIDE
You get flavor. You get fun. You get into WL Community, where bourbon’s best-kept secrets are shared. From tasting tips to rare bottle drops, you’ll never drink alone again.
Over 5000+ Customers Love Us
Hear it from the Whiskey Library Community
Can't Believe I Actually Won
"I legit screamed when I saw the email — I WON THE PAPPY VAN WINKLE. I’ve entered a dozen raffles and never even came close. But this time, it showed up at my door. And the box already came loaded with top-shelf bottles I would’ve paid full price for. No clue how Whiskey Library does it, but they’ve got a fan for life. Absolute legends." - Alyssa Greene
I don't how how they are making money on this
"I’ll admit, I was a little bummed I didn’t win the Pappy — I had the Discord open like it was a live draft. But when my box showed up? Unreal. A Gatsby Remus (worth the price alone), plus a Doc Holliday 7-Year, Penelope Toasted Barrel, and two free glasses. I genuinely don’t know how they’re making money on these. This isn’t some gimmick — it’s the real deal." - Calvin Stewart
Found my new favorite
"My wife got me the Bourbon Mystery Box as a gift, and I figured it’d be a fun little surprise. But when I opened it and saw the Doc Holliday 10-Year, I was curious. One pour later, I was in love. It’s smooth, rich, and has this depth I didn’t expect. That bottle changed the way I think about bourbon. I used to grab whatever looked familiar — now I find myself actually tasting, slowing down, and appreciating what’s in the glass. What started as a thoughtful gift turned into something I genuinely look forward to each month." - Miguel Alvarez
Got it as a gift, he loved it
"So far we’ve placed two orders. Fast shipping, great products. The mystery box was an awesome surprise for my husband he like everything in there to build his collection." - Priya Kapoor
Was A birthday present
"As for the content in the bottle, I wouldn't know yet. We are waiting for a 50th birthday to open it up. The package was nicely shipped, no damages and the inside was just perfect. My husband and our friend really enjoyed opening it up and had a great smile the rest of the day!! Thank you!" - Dana Brooks
Finally, a Club That Actually Delivers
"Straightforward, zero gimmicks, and a breath of fresh air in a world of flashy ‘luxury’ clubs that never deliver what they promise. Every month feels curated for me, not mass-produced for the crowd.Quality drams, fair cost, end of story" - Alan Rossi
Unlock Premium Perks & Privileges
Exclusive Single barrel Picks
Handpicked. Small batch. Never repeated. Our single-barrel releases are reserved for those who sip like insiders.
Early Access to New Releases
While others wait, you pour. Members get first access to limited releases before they sell out—or show up online for triple the price.
Member Only Events & Discounts
You’re not just buying whisky—you’re getting into the room where it happens. Private events, member-only drams, and exclusive discounts you won’t find anywhere else.
Monthly Allocation Raffel
Each month, one legendary bottle. One lucky winner. One more reason to be part of the club.
Virtual Tastings with Master Distillers
Learn directly from the legends. Our virtual tastings put you face-to-face with the people who make the magic.
Bourbon Mystery Box
- 🥃 2–4 Rare & Craft Bourbons (Valued $329+)
- 👨👩👧👦 Access to the Whiskey Library Community ($95 Value)
- 🥇 A Shot at Getting a Pappy Van Winkle ($1000 Value)
- 🚙 Free Shipping ($25 Value)
- 🍹 Members Only Events ($100 value)
🎟️ Free $25 Gift Card and Rock Glasses for the First 500 Members ($45 Value)
-
Jul 18th Ordered -
Jul 18th - Jul 20th Order Ready -
Jul 20th - Jul 25th Delievered
Customer Reviews
Based on 34 reviews
91%
(31)
6%
(2)
3%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
M
I was skeptical but thought id try it and see. Got in my first mystery box and got 3 hard to find bottles of bourbon and checked MSRP, to see if a got a bargain. To my surprise the bourbons were more than the mystery box cost. Now waiting to see if this continues on my next box.
S
Very happy with the selection received. Great additions to my collection. Nothing that I typically see on the shelf in my area. Looking forward to my next box
M
It's so fun opening the box to see which bottles you've received, like Christmas as a kid. I received 4 bottles, none of which I'd ever had or even seen in a store. The mystery box is perfect for finding new bottles to try.
A
I was pleased with my first Mystery Box. A nice assortment of products. Various proofs and finishes. None of these are bottles that I have been “searching for” and probably would not have picked them off the shelf, but that is something I kind of like about the Mystery Box. The Remus Repeal Reserve VIII was a solid pour. I am looking forward to trying out the Doc Holiday 10yr Cask Strength and the WWS 10yr Couture Collection. I am excited to get my next shipment in a few months!
N
This is my second mystery box (first with whiskey library) and I'm very excited about the selection. All high.proof and hoping they are all bangers.
FAQ's
What if I don’t like what I get?
If your first sip doesn’t impress, we’ll credit you the value of the bottle (up to $100) —no return needed. Valid for one bottle per box within 30 days of delivery.
What's inside the Mystery Box?
Each box includes 2–4 premium bourbons—from small-batch craft bottles to rare single barrels. You’ll also get tasting notes, exclusive stickers, and the occasional bonus like branded glassware.
Can I choose what’s in the box?
No—and that’s the thrill. Our team curates each box to surprise and impress, pulling from both well-loved and hard-to-find bottles.
Are the bottles rare?
Yes. We source from private picks, craft distilleries, and limited releases. Some boxes even contain allocated or collectible bottles you won’t find on local shelves.
Is it a subscription?
Only if you want it to be.
You can buy a single box or subscribe to receive a new Mystery Box every 3 or 6 months—no pressure, no commitment.
How long does shipping take?
We ship within 48 hours. Most boxes arrive in 5 business days or less.
Can I win something legendary?
Absolutely. Select boxes are randomly upgraded with ultra-rare bottles like BTAC, Weller, or even Pappy Van Winkle.