Skip to content
  • Home
  • Bourbon Mystery Box
  • Bottle Shop
  • Contact Us
Login
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
Search
Whiskey Library LLC
  • Home
  • Bourbon Mystery Box
  • Bottle Shop
  • Contact Us
Search Login Cart 0
Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Not sure where to start?
Try these collections:

  • Best Sellers
Spend $299.00 more to reach free shipping!
    Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout
    Subtotal
    $0.00 USD
    Recently viewed
    Search
    Bourbon Mystery Box

    Bourbon Mystery Box

    233 reviews
    Sale price$330.00Regular price $399.99 17% Off

    Stop chasing dusty liquor shelves and let the Bourbon Mystery Box bring the hunt to you. Each month, Whiskey Library delivers a surprise lineup of hand-picked craft and allocated bourbons—always worth $329+—so you feel like an industry insider the moment it lands on your doorstep. Unboxing isn’t just opening bottles; it’s unlocking stories you’ll retell at every pour. Our bulk-buying power and distillery-direct relationships fill your shelf with rare gems most drinkers only see online—without paying secondary-market markups or wasting weekends on bottle hunts. A VIP Welcome Kit for the first 500 members (etched glasses plus a $24 gift card) turns day one into an instant flex, and inside our private community you can trade tasting notes, catch early drop alerts, and share your latest scores with fellow enthusiasts. Inventory is capped each cycle, swap FOMO for front-row access and start pouring bourbon that earns real bragging rights.

    Sale price$330.00Regular price $399.99 17% Off

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 233 reviews
    Write a review
    86%
    (200)
    11%
    (25)
    3%
    (7)
    0%
    (1)
    0%
    (0)
    S
    Samuel D.
    Enjoyable except 1

    First West and Moonlight Mayhem we very enjoyable to sip. Unfortunately I did not deal the same way for the Rough Rider 8 year.

    User picture
    M
    Mike D.
    First Mystery Box Tasting

    Stellum was our favorite and it didn’t last the evening. Doc Holiday was second and had a nice lingering spice on the palate. 15 Stars was a nice blend and just okay. Rough Rider was a little too strong for my taste just okay, but wouldn’t buy another one. Looking forward to our next box. Very interested in wheated and wheat whiskeys. Hoping to see some in the next box.

    User picture User picture User picture User picture User picture
    A
    Altoris L.
    Amazing value for top tier bottles

    Just received my first sub subscription and was extremely impressed. I received about a $600 box of bourbon for pretty much half the price and not just expensive bottles that are a gimmick, but actual good quality and great tasting notes.

    User picture
    C
    Christopher Doud
    Well worth it!

    Including the gift bottle Doc Holliday, my box had FIVE bottles- Looking forward to tasting them! Currently, I'm just basking in the glow! Thanks WL!

    User picture
    G
    Gary Michell
    Just Arrived

    Wow! My Mystery Box just arrived. I read the reviews on my new bottles and I am very happy with the selections. I have not taste tested any yet, but it looks like a great selection and value. Can't wait to taste.

    User picture
    Load More
    Whiskey Library

    Northport Location

    83 Main Street
    Northport, NY 11768
    Facebook Facebook Facebook

    Info

    • Contact us
    • Shipping Policy
    • Returns policy
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service
    • Referral Program

    Our Community

    Connect with fellow whiskey enthusiasts, get exclusive drops & insider access.

    Join Community
    Payment methods
    © 2025 Whiskey Library | All Rights Reserved
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.