Excellent 4.8 Rated by 9,000+ Members

Get Up To $275 In Bonuses With Your First 3 Boxes

3 to 4 full-size rare craft bourbons in every box. We buy the barrels direct from craft distilleries, so you get bottles your store does not carry.

$330+ of whiskey in every box

Hate a bottle? We credit you back

Free shipping. Skip, pause or cancel any time

Get My Connoisseur Box →
The Mystery Bourbon Box with bottles, tasting glasses, a Whiskey Library hat, a gift card and The Field Guide To Whiskey on a tablet
  • Hard-to-find bottles
  • Over 100 barrels picked for our club
  • Credit back on any bottle
  • Over 9,000 members
  • Shipping is free
  • Over 33,000 boxes shipped
  • Ships to 40 states and DC
Customer looking at bottles on shelves

Sick of Hunting Stores for Allocated Bottles?

If you're a collector (or want to become one), you already know:

  • The best bourbons never make it to shelves
  • Retailers mark up bottles 3–4x
  • You waste time driving from store to store
  • You still never know if you'll like what you find

The distribution system is broken.
The good bottles rarely reach regular customers.

The Bourbon Mystery Box with bottles
THE NEW WAY

Introducing The Bourbon Mystery Box

A more exciting way to discover exceptional bourbon without hunting, guessing, or overpaying.

  • Rare bourbons you’ll never find on the shelves
  • Curated bottles chosen by real bourbon drinkers
  • Every box is always worth more than you pay
  • Full credit back if a bottle isn’t your taste
  • Delivered fast, secure & free right to your door

All possible because we work directly with craft distilleries, no middlemen, no retail mark-ups.

We buy the barrels.

Direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers.

Both names on the label.

Ours and theirs, so you can check.

Credit back.

On any bottle you do not like.

How It Works

1

Choose how often.

One time, monthly, every 2 months or every 3.

2

Your box arrives.

With glasses and the field guide in order 1, a hat and $25 credit in order 2, and your bonus bottle in box 3.

3

We learn what you like.

We learn from your preferences and improve your boxes over time.

The open Mystery Bourbon Box with three bottles (Jimmy Red, Rough Rider, New Louisville), the 15 Stars Triple Cask bonus bottle, a Whiskey Library hat, a $25 gift card, two tasting glasses and the field guide. $330+ of whiskey in every box. Up to $275 in bonuses across your first 3 ordersWhat is inside your Connoisseur Mystery Box: 3 to 4 full-size bottles, free shipping, two Whiskey Library glasses, tasting notes, the digital field guide, and 15 Stars in box 3How the Bourbon Mystery Box subscription works: join the Mystery Box and receive 3 to 4 bottles, we curate your bottles, unbox, taste and enjoy, with credit back on a bottle that is not for youOur credit back guarantee: tell us which bottle you do not love, get store credit back, use it on any bottle from our shop

Excellent 4.8 | Rated by 9,000+ Members

The Connoisseur Bourbon Mystery Box

3 to 4 full-size bottles a box.

We buy the barrels ourselves, direct from craft distilleries and independent bottlers. Single barrels and small blends, with both names on the label. We learn from your preferences and improve your boxes over time.

$279.97/mo

$330.00

Save $50 a box
Claim My Connoisseur Box$279.97

Skip, pause or cancel any time before your next billing date.

  • Visa
  • American Express
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Discover
  • Shop Pay
  • Apple Pay
  • Google Pay

Hate a bottle? We credit you back.

Any bottle you do not like, credited back, up to the value you paid for the box. It is store credit, and it spends on anything in the bottle shop. No questions asked.

Ships in 1 to 2 business days. Arrives 5 to 8 business days after it ships. An adult signs for it.

What’s Inside Each Mystery Box
  • 3–4 hand-picked bourbons you’ll almost never see on local shelves
  • A mix of rare craft bottles, limited drops, and distillery exclusives
  • Full-size bottles only (no minis, no samples, no repeats)
  • Distillery notes, tasting profiles & bottle stories included
  • Fast shipping (48 hours), premium secure packaging

Subscription Terms

  • No commitment: skip or cancel anytime with one click
  • Free shipping on every box
  • Full credit-back guarantee on any bottle you don’t enjoy
Why Bourbon Drinkers Love This Box
  • Discover bottles you’d never find by hunting store to store
  • Build a rare, impressive collection, without the chase
  • Always receive $30–$90+ more value than what you pay
  • Try new distilleries without wasting money on bottles you may not like
  • Perfect for sipping, collecting, or showing off to friends
  • A monthly “unboxing moment” you genuinely look forward to
Why We’re Different

The Mystery Box That Actually Delivers Real Value:

  • We work directly with craft distilleries, no middlemen, no retail markup
  • Our team rejects over 90% of bottles we sample
  • Every shipment is guaranteed to be worth more than the price you pay
  • No filler, no warehouse overruns, no bottles “nobody wants”
  • Risk-free with our full credit-back guarantee
Our Curation Process

Our buyers spend their mornings pulling barrel thieves at craft distilleries like Wilderness Trail, New Riff, and Old Forester’s Single Barrel program. They taste 50+ samples to find the 3 that matter. No standing in line. No lottery losses. Just exceptional bourbon delivered monthly.

  • Barrel by barrel. Hand-selected at the source, not from a catalog
  • The 6% that survive. Our 94% rejection rate is your quality guarantee
  • Zero risk. Full credit for any bottle that doesn’t hit your palate
Our Credit-Back Guarantee

If a bottle simply isn’t your taste, you get full credit back, no questions asked.

We stand behind every pick we send, and we want you to love every bottle. This guarantee makes your membership completely risk-free and ensures you only pay for bourbon you truly enjoy.

What Bourbon Drinkers Like You Are Saying

Whiskey Library community
Whiskey Library Community

Join the Club. Build Your Collection.

  • We count it at our own shelf prices, the prices in our bottle shop.
  • Over 100 barrels picked for our club, with both names on the label.
  • Any bottle you do not like, credited back, up to the value you paid for the box. It is store credit, and it spends on anything in the bottle shop. No questions asked.
  • Shipping is free. Boxes ship in 1 to 2 business days and arrive 5 to 8 business days after they ship. An adult has to sign for it.
  • Glasses and the field guide with order 1. The hat and a $25 credit with order 2. The bonus bottle in box 3.
  • You do not get the same bottle twice.
Get My Connoisseur Box →

Free shipping. Credit back on any bottle you do not like.

The Mystery Bourbon Box with five bottles, tasting glasses, a hat, a gift card and the field guide
The Mystery Bourbon Box with five bottles, tasting glasses, a hat, a gift card and the field guide
WHY COLLECTORS LOVE IT

Get What Others Hunt For, Without the Chase

  • Not sure you will like it? Any bottle you do not like is credited back.
  • Too much whiskey? Choose every 2 months or every 3.
  • Do not want a subscription? Buy one box.
  • Worried about being locked in? Skip, pause or cancel any time.
Get My Connoisseur Box →
Free shipping. Credit back on any bottle you do not like.

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Choose every 2 months or every 3 months when you order. You can also skip a month or pause any time. One member, Orville Burks: "I chose the every three month option. Depending on my next box I may need to change that to monthly!"
  • We count it at our own shelf prices, the prices in our bottle shop. On that count boxes hold about 1.2 times their price in whiskey, and 98.8% of boxes were worth more than the member paid.
  • Our own barrel picks show up more from box two on. Box one leans on a maker's own range, so you know the house before you meet the one-off barrel. We learn from your preferences and improve your boxes over time.
  • Some of them, yes. Some are bottles from a maker's own range. Others are barrels we picked ourselves, with both names on the label, and those are not sold anywhere else. Over 100 barrels picked for our club so far. Yes, you can buy Frey Ranch. No, you cannot buy that one.
  • Over 9,000 members and over 33,000 boxes shipped since May 2025. Every bottle is a full-size bottle from a named maker, and any bottle you do not like is credited back.
  • The maker's name is on every label. We buy direct from craft distilleries and from independent bottlers, and when we pick a barrel both names go on the label, ours and theirs.
  • No. We buy the barrels and the bottles ourselves, for the club. Over 400 different bottles from over 150 brands have gone out so far, and 81% of them are 100 proof or higher.
  • We credit you back, up to the value you paid for the box. No questions asked. It is store credit, not a refund, and it spends on anything in the bottle shop.
  • Yes. Pick One time. It is $330.00, with no renewal, and it comes with the tasting glasses and the field guide. One member, TLTIII-GA: "Even if you don't subscribe, you've gotta try it at least once. You won't be disappointed."
  • No. Skip a month, pause or cancel any time before your next billing date. There is no three month commitment. The only thing you miss is the bonuses that had not arrived yet.
  • 99.8% of bottles sent to returning members were not repeats. We track what we have sent you and what you have bought in the bottle shop.
  • Glasses and the field guide with order 1. The hat and a $25 credit with order 2. The bonus bottle in box 3.
  • Shipping is free to 40 states and DC. Boxes ship in 1 to 2 business days and arrive 5 to 8 business days after they ship. UPS delivers it, and an adult has to sign for it.