"Elegance over intensity"
Softer, sweeter, incredibly approachable. Wheated mash bills from craft distilleries.
"Complexity without the punch"
Classic bourbon character. Sweet corn balanced with toasted oak and just enough spice.
"Intensity and character"
Spicy, complex, full of character. Bold mash bills and bigger proofs that reward attention.
Includes 3–4 bottles
$279 .99 /month
Includes 2–3 bottles
$149 .99 /month
Includes 1–2 bottles
$99 .99 /month
Your First 3 Months of Rewards
Digital PDF
$20 Value
WL Hat +25$ Credit
$45 Value
15 StarsThree Ports
$179 Value
Free shipping on ALL orders
FREE
Your First 3 Months of Rewards
Digital PDF
$20 Value
WL Hat +15$ Credit
$45 Value
Clyde May'sSingle Barrel
$80 Value
Free shipping on ALL orders
FREE
Skip or cancel anytime Full credit-back guarantee Every box worth more than you pay
Enjoy every bottle, or get a credit back.
If a bottle doesn’t hit the spot, we credit your account — no hassle, no questions asked.
Order now to receive on
The Mystery Box That Actually Delivers Real Value:
Our buyers spend their mornings pulling barrel thieves at craft distilleries like Wilderness Trail, New Riff, and Old Forester’s Single Barrel program. They taste 50+ samples to find the 3 that matter. No standing in line. No lottery losses. Just exceptional bourbon delivered monthly.
If a bottle simply isn’t your taste, you get full credit back – no questions asked.
We stand behind every pick we send, and we want you to love every bottle. This guarantee makes your membership completely risk-free and ensures you only pay for bourbon you truly enjoy.
Billing
First Box charged today. Same date each month – you’ll get a reminder email 3 days before.
Skip or pause anytime
Need a break? One click from your account – no phone calls, no forms, no reason needed.
Cancel anytime
Instantly. Log in, click Cancel, done. No waiting period, no retention calls, no cancellation fee.
WHAT’S INSIDE
Every Mystery Box is packed with real, respected craft bourbon - not filler, not no-names:
Nulu
Jimmy Red
First West
Castle & Key
Rough Rider
Doc Swinsons
Peerless
15 Stars Three Ports
Dark Arts
Kluke
Skip or cancel anytime Full credit-back guarantee Every box worth more than you pay
Hand-Picked Craft Bourbons
Curated by experts who taste 50+ samples to find the 3 that make the cut. Only 6% of bottles we sample make it to your door.
Guaranteed Value Every Shipment
$100+ for Starter, $170+ for Explorer, $330+ for Connoisseur. Your box is always worth more than you pay or we credit you back.
Credit-Back Guarantee
If a bottle isn't your taste, you get full credit back. No questions asked. Your membership is completely risk-free.
Free Shipping on All Orders
Every mystery box ships free — all tiers included. Explorer and Connoisseur members also get free shipping on all additional shop orders. Forever.
Members-Only Allocated Releases
First access to rare single-barrel picks and limited releases at true MSRP. The bottles others line up for, delivered to your door.
Member Status & Rewards
Unlock Silver, Gold, and Platinum status as you build your collection. Higher tiers = better access, exclusive pricing, and surprise perks.
We taste 50+ samples weekly...
but for Smooth Sippers like you, we're hunting for something specific: wheated mash bills, vanilla-forward profiles, and bottles under 100 proof that let the sweet grain shine through.
Our buyers focus on distilleries known for elegance over intensity – Maker's Mark's experimental releases, Wilderness Trail's wheated program, soft-grain craft distilleries.
They reject 94% of what they taste. You get the 6% that fits your profile perfectly.
but for Oak & Grain Explorers like you, we're hunting for something specific: traditional corn-forward bourbon with character – think toasted oak, balanced spice, and bottles that reward attention without overwhelming.
Our buyers focus on distilleries doing classic bourbon the right way – New Riff’s bonded expressions, Old Forester’s barrel finishes, heritage distilleries exploring unique grain ratios.
They reject 94% of what they taste. You get the 6% that fits your profile perfectly.
but for Bold Pioneers like you, we're hunting for something specific: high-rye expressions, barrel-proof releases, and bourbons with serious spice & structure – black pepper, dark fruit, cinnamon heat.
Our buyers focus on distilleries known for intensity and character – cask-strength programs, high-rye mash bills, craft distilleries pushing proof and flavor.
They reject 94% of what they taste. You get the 6% that fits your profile perfectly.
Only had one of the 5 bottles in the past, and never heard of the others. Well worth the $279 to get $500 in bourbon that I wouldn’t have otherwise tasted. Can’t wait to see what’s next!
Verified Customer
I’m still pretty new to the bourbon scene and exploring the huge variety that’s out there. One place that really stood out to me is the Whiskey Library. It’s an incredible site with an amazing selection that you do not see in your typical brick and mortar. Whether you’re a rookie just starting your bourbon journey or a seasoned bourbon drinker, I highly recommend making the Whiskey Library a must-visit. There’s something for everyone and it is a fantastic way to expand your palate.
Verified Customer
Just started trying them and off the bat the Stellum is fantastic; cherry pie with brown sugar and oak on the nose, palate is layered with chocolate, toffee, and cinnamon spice. Then finishes oh so smooth with a mild bite at the end. At 115 proof this thing will sneak up on you! Fingers crossed the Easter bunny brings me another box!
Verified Customer
After the third shipment, I finally received my two sniffer glasses that were not broken. Whiskey library has a great customer service team and addressed my broken glasses immediately by sending out another shipment after I contacted them. The bourbon has been great so far. Thank you
Verified Customer
Well worth the price, the whiskey you receive is AWESOME!!! Thanks Whiskey Library!!!
Verified Customer
The box had several bourbons I am not able to buy locally. The wife and I really enjoyed doing a sampling. The jimmy red bourbon is now one of our favorites.
Verified Customer
I was pleased with my first box! The products were delivered just as promised by the company! I am excited to see what products are in my next box! No complaints or issues just great whiskey!
Thanks
Verified Customer
You get full credit — no questions, no hoops. If a bottle doesn't hit your palate, contact us and we'll apply the value to your next order. We stand behind every pick we ship.
We're not a retailer — we don't stock shelves or sell what's easy to get. We're a curation team that works directly with craft distilleries, hand-selecting barrels at the source. Our buyers taste 50+ samples weekly and reject 94% of what they try. The 6% that survive end up in your box.
Every bottle is a genuine craft pick from distilleries like Nulu, Jimmy Red, Frey Ranch, and First West — names respected in the bourbon world, not mass-market fillers. Your box is always guaranteed to be worth more than you pay, and if a bottle doesn't hit your palate, you get full credit back.
It's a subscription — but a flexible one. Skip a month, pause, or cancel anytime before your next billing date. No penalties, no calls to make. Manage everything directly from your account.
The Starter Box ($99/mo) is perfect if you're new to craft bourbon or want a low-commitment way to explore. You'll receive 1–2 premium craft bottles each month — a great way to discover what you like.
The Explorer Box ($149/mo) is built for the enthusiast who wants to discover — a mix of styles, distilleries, and flavor profiles, curated for range and approachability. Includes 2–3 bottles plus glassware and a gift card.
The Connoisseur Box ($279/mo) is built for the collector — barrel-numbered expressions, aged releases, and distillery-exclusive picks that rarely make it onto any shelf. Includes 3–4 bottles plus glassware and a gift card. All three are hand-selected by our curation team. The Connoisseur just goes deeper.
It happens occasionally. If you receive a bottle you already own, contact us and we'll work something out. Our goal is for every box to feel like a find, not a repeat.
Orders ship within 1–2 business days and typically arrive in 4–5 business days. You'll get a tracking link the moment your box leaves our hands. Every bottle is packed securely — signature required on delivery.
