Customer Reviews

Based on 31 reviews
90%
(28)
6%
(2)
3%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
A
Adam Love
First Mystery Box

I was pleased with my first Mystery Box. A nice assortment of products. Various proofs and finishes. None of these are bottles that I have been “searching for” and probably would not have picked them off the shelf, but that is something I kind of like about the Mystery Box. The Remus Repeal Reserve VIII was a solid pour. I am looking forward to trying out the Doc Holiday 10yr Cask Strength and the WWS 10yr Couture Collection. I am excited to get my next shipment in a few months!

N
Nick D
High proof bangers

This is my second mystery box (first with whiskey library) and I'm very excited about the selection. All high.proof and hoping they are all bangers.

G
Gregory Belknap
No regrets

Whiskey Library made no money off me this month. Fantastic Mystery box! Can’t wait till next month. Shipping was faster than expected.

K
Karl U
No brainer!

I didn’t want a little two-shot sipper , so I took a shot here. I was prepared to be ho-hummed with good-but-not-great bottles. I was very pleasantly surprised! None of these are easily sourced in my market. And that’s a lot of bang-for-the-MSRP-buck sitting there. Two are excellent pours, though, admittedly, the Rough Rider is not to my personal palate. But half the fun is exploring something new that challenges you.

Looking forward to my next box!

A
Art Garrett
Very Pleased with my first offering

Of course looking for the Mother load. But these are fine.