Γ
Skip to content
  • Home
  • Bourbon Mystery Box
    • Connoisseur Box
    • Explorer Box
  • Bottle Shop
  • Gift Card
  • Contact Us
Login
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
Search
Whiskey Library LLC
  • Home
  • Bourbon Mystery Box
    • Connoisseur Box

    • Explorer Box

  • Bottle Shop
  • Gift Card
  • Contact Us
Search Login Cart 0
Cart

Your cart is currently empty.

Not sure where to start?
Try these collections:

  • Best Sellers
Spend $299.00 more to reach free shipping!
    Taxes and shipping calculated at checkout
    Subtotal
    $0.00 USD
    Recently viewed
    Search
    Dark Arts Whiskey House 5 Years Old Cask Strength Bourbon Finished in Toasted Mizunara Staves Whiskey Library PBJ Blend 750ml
    Dark Arts Whiskey House 5 Years Old Cask Strength Bourbon Finished in Toasted Mizunara Staves Whiskey Library PBJ Blend 750ml

    Dark Arts Whiskey House 5 Years Old Cask Strength Bourbon Finished in Toasted Mizunara Staves Whiskey Library PBJ Blend 750ml

    5 reviews
    $69.99
    Out of stock

    Dark Arts Whiskey House Cask Strength Whiskey Library PBJ Blend (750ml) is a bold, playful, and richly layered bourbon blend crafted exclusively for Whiskey Library. This unique single barrel pick—nicknamed the "PBJ Blend"—delivers a flavor profile reminiscent of peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, offering waves of roasted peanut, berry compote, vanilla, and toasted oak. Bottled at full cask strength and unfiltered, it packs intense flavor and a velvety mouthfeel, finishing with a sweet-savory interplay of nutty warmth and fruity richness. A creative and delicious expression from Dark Arts Whiskey House, this barrel pick is a true conversation piece for adventurous palates.

    $69.99

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 5 reviews
    Write a review
    60%
    (3)
    40%
    (2)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    L
    Lisa
    Mystery box reviews

    This was in one of the early deliveries, for a 5 year, lower priced cask strength this was surprisingly good. Smooth with the toasted oak flavor and smell.
    My 1-10 rating: 7 The bottle is pretty cool too!

    G
    Gage R.
    Definitely worth trying

    This wasn't a bourbon I drank every night but it was definitely a good one. Flavor profile definitely has those peanut butter notes and smooth finish. It's more towards that nice fall season bourbon for me. Worth a try for sure.

    C
    Christopher Knox
    Didn’t last long

    This bourbon was so dang good, barely lasted 2 days between my wife and I. Don’t hesitate on grabbing one

    K
    Kevin
    A worthy purchase and unique flavor

    This is tasty! Maybe it's just because I was thinking about peanut butter and jelly when I sipped it, but it definitely gave me memories of eating peanut butter and jelly sandwiches! It's smooth enough and has enough flavor to be shipped neat. This won't win whiskey of the year, but it is definitely worth having on your shelf!

    G
    Greg
    Delicious

    Get a back up of this one. Absolute joy!

    Whiskey Library

    Northport Location

    83 Main Street
    Northport, NY 11768
    Facebook Facebook Facebook

    Info

    • Contact us
    • Shipping Policy
    • Returns policy
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service
    • Referral Program

    Our Community

    Connect with fellow whiskey enthusiasts, get exclusive drops & insider access.

    Join Community
    Payment methods
    © 2025 Whiskey Library | All Rights Reserved
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.